Then Jesus left Galilee and went north to the region of Tyre and Sidon. A Gentile woman who lived there came to him, pleading, “Have mercy on me, O Lord, Son of David! For my daughter is possessed by a demon that torments her severely.” But Jesus gave her no reply, not even a word. Then his disciples urged him to send her away. “Tell her to go away,” they said. “She is bothering us with all her begging.” Then Jesus said to the woman, “I was sent only to help God’s lost sheep—the people of Israel.” But she came and worshiped him, pleading again, “Lord, help me!” Jesus responded, “It isn’t right to take food from the children and throw it to the dogs.” She replied, “That’s true, Lord, but even dogs are allowed to eat the scraps that fall beneath their masters’ table.” “Dear woman,” Jesus said to her, “your faith is great. Your request is granted.” And her daughter was instantly healed. Matthew 15:21-28 (New Living Translation)
Every now-and-then I go down to the Corning Preserve in Albany and sit by the Hudson and read and chill. Today I chilled alright as I sat at one of the picnic tables with snow on the ground and 20 degree temperatures. While I was reading (Oliver Twist by Charles Dickens by-the-way) I noticed this guy that I see every single time that I go to the Preserve. You see, he lives on a bench next to the parking lot. Year round. Today he was bundled up in what looked like 7 or 8 layers of coats and maybe 3 or 4 pants. He was rummaging through the trash, looking for...what? Food? A nickel deposit bottle? I don't know. When I got home I warmed up for a little while as I waited for my wife to make me a sandwich. When she so kindly brought it to me in the living room so I could eat it sitting on the sofa watching a basketball game, I noticed the crumbs on the wooden plate thing that I always eat my sandwiches from. Then...I started thinking about that guy at the Preserve and the woman from this story.
Crumbs. That’s all she is looking for. Crumbs. Not the whole loaf. Not even a slice. Just crumbs. Small crusty crumbs that fall over the edge of the table. And she knows that he can give her what she needs. She has heard about this Jewish messiah, Jesus of Nazareth. He turns clear, cool water into rich, red wine. He takes a few loaves and fishes from one boy and feeds thousands. Now he comes out to the borders of Palestine where she and her tormented daughter live on the edge of existence. It’s been a long time since this woman has enjoyed a banquet. She has almost forgotten how to claim her place at the table. But she has heard about Jesus of Nazareth. She knows he has something from God to feed people. And she intends to get some of that something for her daughter. Crumbs. She will take crumbs if that is all she can get.
We don’t know what finally pushes the woman over the edge. The writer of Matthew doesn’t tell us. We can only imagine. We can only presume to imagine. Perhaps she sits at her empty table one day. Her house is small, the afternoon heat is unbearable. And then, her young daughter, seized by a fit, falls to the dirt floor in convulsions. No, the gospel writer does not give us much background. We can only presume to imagine that this desperate woman has had enough. Suddenly, this woman pushes away from an empty table and runs out the door. Out the door and down the road. Desperate for crumbs. Then she sees Jesus of Nazareth.
It’s interesting, isn’t it? It seems that Jesus has had enough as well. He has had enough of rigid, hypocritical Pharasaic rules—what Matthew calls “the tradition of the elders.” He has had enough of deaf, dumb disciples who stumble around blindly and just don’t get it. Jesus leaves the cool waters of the Galilee to travel northwest on dusty roads. Out on the far edges of Israel. Out there—figuratively and literally—on the border. “On the boundary between the old and the new, between male and female, between Jew and Gentile, between friend and enemy, between the holy and the demonic.” It is here, on the edge of existence, where we see great faith. From somewhere deep inside her, this woman seizes the tiny crumbs of faith that remain. She seizes that faith, strides out the door and down the dusty road.
As she approaches Jesus of Nazareth, she starts shouting: “Have mercy on me, Lord, Son of David!” Shrieking. Screaming. Shouting. This word “shouting” used by the gospel writer is the same word used “in Revelation 12:2 to describe the cries of a woman in labor pains.” So, just as this woman once cried out as she gave birth to her daughter, she now cries out in a struggle to give health and wholeness to that child. She knows that she, a Canaanite woman, with no better status than a dog, is not worthy to gather up the crumbs under the table. Yet she knows something about God’s mercy that the Pharisees and scribes do not know. She knows something that even Jesus’ disciples do not know. She knows that God’s mercy is wide and broad and wonderfully kind and faithful and bountiful. God’s divine love is even wider—even wider—than the love of the human Jesus of Nazareth. It is in this certain knowledge that the Canaanite woman dares to shout for God’s mercy as she kneels in front of the human Jesus.
What does she get for her trouble? At first, nothing—except stony silence. Jesus ignores her and the disciples probably roll their eyes. But when she continues to shout, the disciples are pushed over the edge. Get rid of this woman, Jesus. Send her away, will you? We had enough crazy people to deal with in Galilee, and they were our own kind. Now we’ve got crazy foreigners ranting and raving in the road. Do something. Do anything. Just get rid of her, okay? Enough already! Jesus responds, but not to the woman kneeling before him. He ignores the woman, and responds to the disciples. “I was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel,” he says firmly. I know who I am. I am Israel’s messiah. My own people sit in darkness and need to see a great light. I was sent to bring my own people healing, justice, mercy. I am a Jew—“the Jew who stands as the culmination of all of Israel’s history.” Yes, and more than a messiah for Israel. The human and historic Jesus claims his identity as Israel’s messiah.
And yet this woman who lives on the edges, on the margins, claims even more than Jesus does himself. For she sees beyond the Jewish man in front of her: her vision extends back in history to the Davidic royal line, and forward in history to the crucified and risen Christ. This Jewish messiah before whom she kneels is a fulcrum for faith for thousands of people: those who live bountiful, mainstream lives, and those who struggle for crumbs on the edges of life. Jesus is the messiah of Israel. And Jesus is the savior of the entire world.
The Pharisees and scribes may not get it. The disciples may not get it. But this poor Canaanite woman gets it. Jesus says, “It is not fair to take the children’s food and throw it to the dogs.” And the woman turns the metaphor back on him with sharp and sure retort. “Yes, Lord, yet even the dogs eat the crumbs that fall from their master’s table.” Here is the kind of fierce, ferocious faith that will transform a world. So out of a faith that persists and struggles, out of a faith that seizes and shouts for attention, the woman receives what she demands. Healing for her daughter. Mercy that is wide and broad and wonderfully kind and faithful and bountiful.
So what? What can this story possibly mean for me—who did not experience the historical, human Jesus sent to save his own people? After a lifetime of church, belief, disbelief, re-belief have I really forgotten a first century Jewish messiah even as I remember a crucified and risen Christ in the breaking of bread and in my prayers? I—well educated, upper middle class, wealthy in comparison to most of the world—have all, and more, than I need. I do not grovel for crumbs under anyone’s table. My life is bountiful and rich.
Here is the sharp edge of this gospel reading. Because I claim my place at God’s table, as God’s son, I have claimed a place not only of privilege, but one of responsibility. This place requires me to feed my brothers and sisters. Crumbs. That’s all they are looking for. Crumbs. Not the whole loaf. Not even a slice. Just crumbs. I, of course, want the whole loaf...and usually get it. I drive a good car. They take buses or they walk. I have a pension plan. They lack basic health insurance so they must bring crying babies to the Emergency Room at midnight. My wife and I, the two of us, have a nice home with 4 bedrooms. They live in crowded, noisy apartments or on a freezing cold bench at the Corning Preserve. I get a regular paycheck. They cannot keep jobs. Why? Because too many of them slept last night in a shelter. They were kept awake by snoring. An uncomfortable cot. The wailing of hungry babies. And when you fall asleep on the job, you don’t have a job for long.
Crumbs. Like Oliver Twist when he says to the parish workhouse master, they say, "Please, sir, I want some more." They want more than crumbs because deep in their souls, they are hungry and know they deserve more. And yet they often do not know who to ask or how to ask. So they wait. They wait in emergency rooms and welfare lines. They wait in line for sandwiches and coffee at the Rescue Mission on Pearl Street. They bus tables or they serve tables, but I don't let them pull up a chair and eat at that table. Some of them are tired of waiting. Angry at waiting. Sick to death of crumbs. So they get high or drunk and rob convenience stores. They kidnap little girls or rape women and leave their bodies in parks. They strap bombs on their bodies, walk onto crowded buses, and blow themselves up.
The people who live out there on the edges of life are sick to death of waiting for the banquet to begin, so they stand in front of me and demand crumbs. The crucified, risen and ascended Christ asks: When will you feed them? When will you help them learn to read? When will you join Habitat for Humanity and help them build a home? When will you work for justice so there will be peace? When will you look them in the eye and say “Thank you for being my waiter today. You did a good job!?”
Yes, “there’s a wideness in God’s mercy, like the wideness of the sea. There’s a kindness in [God’s] justice which is more than liberty. There is welcome for the sinner, and more graces for the good; there is mercy with the Savior, there is healing in his blood.” Two thousand years ago, a Canaanite woman knew this. God gave her clarity of vision so that she saw far beyond the edge of her empty table to a banquet table. She knew that God’s banquet table is full, and that any crumb from that table would fill her. Way down that dusty road, even beyond the human vision of Jesus of Nazareth, the divine plan of God would feed the whole world, not just part of the world.